Announcement in The Daily Telegraph May 30 2012.

Passed away peacefully aged 91 on 23 May 2012 after a long brave and courageous battle. Dearly beloved husband of Babs and much loved father of Gail, Gylly and Fiona. He will also be mised by son in laws Richard and Brian, grandchildren Melanie, James and Jamie and great-grandchildren Thomas, Robin, Hannah and Richard. Private Service at Reading Crematorium on 8 June 2012.

Former colleagues are welcome to attend a memorial service to celebrate his life at 12 noon Thursday 2 August 2012 at St Margaret’s Church, Harpsden. RG9 4AX. Family flowers only, donations if desired to the Royal British Legion, c/o Tomalin & Sons, 38 Reading Road, Henley on Thames, Oxford RG9 1AG 01491 573370.

Obituary From his daughter Gail

Founder Chairman and Vice-President of the Fleet Air Arm Officers Association. George McCracken (Mac) Rutherford MBE DSC VRD died in the Royal Berkshire Hospital on Wednesday 23rd May 2012 aged 91.

Mac was born in Blackpool and went to school at Oundle from 1935 until 1939. In 1940 Mac reported for duty in the Fleet Air Arm of the Royal Navy commencing training on HMS St Vincent in Gosport, thence to further stations and finally to RCAF Kingston in Canada.

His operational training took place at Royal Naval Air Station (RNAS) Crail, Arbroath, and Machrinash (766 Squadron), where he managed to kill two cows on the top of a hill at night in a Swordfish, which was able to continue flying, eventually crash-landing on Strathy, a satellite of Machrinash.

In July 1942 he joined 841 Squadron flying Albacores operating out of RAF Manston in Kent. He was awarded the DSC ‘for great courage and enterprise’ when he sank 2 e-boats in a squadron off Calais.
[London Gazette 30 November 1943
841 Squadron.
TSub Lt (A) G McC Rutherford RNVR awarded DSC]

He later served in Coltishall, Tangmere, Exeter, St Merryn and Malta. He was transferred to Australia in 1945 being demobilised in April, 1946. Mac joined 1832 Squadron at RNAS Culham, becoming CO in 1948. In July 1949 1832 was the first reserve squadron to go to sea in peacetime, Mac being the CO thus became the first reserve pilot to land on a carrier, Implacable, a feat he later topped in 1956 by also becoming the first reservist to land a jet (sea Hawk) on a carrier, Bulwark. In 1952 1832 was later enlarged becoming the Southern Air Division (SAD), consisting of four Squadrons, Mac becoming the CO with the rank of Commander. The announcement of this promotion was made by Admiral Lord Mountbatten after a squadron inspection following a training exercise at RNAS Hal Far, in Malta. SAD moved to RAF Benson in 1953 and together with all Naval RNR, and RAF Auxiliary Squadrons were disbanded in 1957. Mac became the CO of an RNR photographic interpretation unit for two years, finally retiring from the Reserve in 1970.

London Gazette 7 June 1951
1832 Squadron.
Birthday honours List 1951
ALt Cdr G McC Rutherford DSC RNVR awarded MBE (investiture 7.11.51)

Mac was awarded the VRD in 1955.

On the disbandment of the Reserve Squadrons Mac, following discussions started 10 years earlier in Australia, proposed the formation of a Fleet Air Arm Association. In February 1957 became the Founder Chairman of the now flourishing Fleet Air Arm Officers Association. He was Chairman of the Henley Branch of the British Legion from 1986 until 1997 when he became President.

He married Pamela Ross in 1942 who died in 1973. They had three daughters, Gail, Gillian and Fiona.

After being demobbed, Mac, Pam and Gail moved to Hawick, where Mac trained as a woollen merchant in Pam’s family firm. Having finished his training they all moved to Henley moving first to a small cottage in Grays Road and then on to St Andrews Road. He was a member of Phyllis Court cClub and a regular churchgoer at St Margaret’s Church, Harpsden. He was involved in the formation of the original Henley Squash Club and a keen supporter of Henley Rugby Club.

He married Babs Dooris in 1975 and retired in 1986.Mac and Babs Rutherford lived in Manor Road, Henley until October 2006 when sadly they had to move to Huntercombe Hall as they needed fulltime care.

Obituary from Peter Hore (c)

Commander ‘Mac’ Rutherford, who has died aged 91, flew dangerous night-time missions over the English Channel and founded the Fleet Air Arm Officers’ Association.

In July 1942 Rutherford volunteered to join 841 Naval Air Squadron for special duties – flying the black-painted Fairey Albacores which, controlled by RAF plotters, flew on night raids against enemy shipping in the Narrow Seas, between England and Europe, and over the next year Rutherford’s squadron carried out 99 night-time attacks in the English Channel.

Typically on the night of 28/29 April 1943, an Albacore of 841 Squadron sighted the phosphorescent wakes of twelve E-boats steaming east at fifteen knots in two columns of six, and attacked at once, while calling up reinforcements. Arriving overhead Rutherford attacked three boats, scoring several near-misses, but his observer dropped flares which enabled a third Albacore to make an accurate bombing run. A fourth aircraft delivered a dive-bombing attack, and when the squadron CO arrived he found “the enemy in a state of chaos” with eight or nine boats steering in various directions, and he delivered his attack. At least one boat was seen in flames, and the disruption of such a large force undoubtedly stopped a major attack developing against the vital coastal convoys sailing to the Thames Estuary.

Then in August 1943 Rutherford was directed onto to a two lines of enemy ships about two miles off Calais, and flying through heavy flak to make his attack he bombed two E-boats which he claimed ‘sunk’. Rutherford then flew back to Manston to re-arm and in his second sortie he bombed another E-boat which was also estimated as a ‘hit’.

Rutherford was awarded the DSC for great courage and enterprise in attacking enemy shipping.

George McCracken Rutherford was born on 30 October 30, 1920 in Blackpool, and educated at Oundle from 1935 until 1939.

In 1940 Rutherford joined the Navy as a Naval Airman Second Class, starting his training at HMS St Vincent in Gosport, and learning to fly at Kingston in Canada.

His operational training took place in Scotland, where in the early hours of August 7, 1942 at Machrihanish he survived a rare accident. As the last of a flight of three aircraft he had already seen the No 1 disappear in cloud, and the No 2 crash into a parked aircraft and fragment into a St Catherine’s wheel of white, red and green lights. As he took off, suddenly he felt and heard a loud bang and the control column was wrenched from him. His instrument readings swung wildly as he grabbed the stick in both hands and, using full rudder to master his direction of flight, slowly climbed to 3,000 ft. As he emerged from cloud his observer looked over the side and reported that a large part of the starboard lower wing, the aileron and the undercarriage were missing. He had just asked his observer if he wanted to bail out, when he saw a hole in the clouds, rapidly descended, and made a one-wheel landing in the middle of an army exercise. Later that morning he was taken to a hilltop where he found two dead cows among the wreckage of his aircraft and was confronted by an angry farmer.

After flying in 841 NAS Rutherford served at Coltishall, Tangmere, Exeter, St Merryn, Malta and Australia, where he was demobilised in April, 1946.

Postwar Rutherford re-trained as a woollen merchant in his wife’s family firm, and settled in the Thames valley.

He kept up his flying skills by joining 1832 RNVR squadron, which he commanded in 1948. The next year he persuaded the Navy that his pilots had sufficient skill to land-on their Seafires at sea, and when called up for its annual fortnight’s training, 1832 became the first reserve squadron to serve at sea, its twenty aircraft achieving 269 landings on the carrier Implacable in seven days of training. In 1952 1832 NAS was enlarged to become Southern Air Division (SAD), consisting of four squadrons, which Rutherford commanded. Then in 1956 Rutherford became the first reservist to land a Seahawk jet on a carrier, Bulwark. His promotion to commander was announced by Admiral Lord Mountbatten after a squadron inspection at the end of a training exercise at RNAS Hal Far, in Malta.

Rutherford was awarded the MBE in 1952 and the VRD in 1955.

The idea of an association of Fleet Air Pilots was born in the Imperial Services Club, Sydney out of the sense of camaraderie amongst naval pilots in the British Pacific Fleet. When in 1957 the RNVR air squadrons were disbanded, Rutherford chaired the first meeting, in the Naval and Military Club in Piccadilly, of the Fleet Air Arm Officers Association, dedicated to commemorating the achievements of the FAA and promoting the cause of naval aviation. From a few hundred founding members, the FAAOA grew to quickly to over 3000 today.

Rutherford was a member of the Phyllis Court Club, Henley, helped to found the Henley Squash Club, and supported Henley Rugby Club. He was a regular churchgoer at St Margaret’s Church, Harpsden, and chairman and later president of the Henley Branch of the British Legion.

Rutherford who died in the Royal Berkshire Hospital on May 23, 2012, married in 1943 Pamela Ross who predeceased him in 1973, and second in 1975 ‘Babs’ Dooris (sic) who survives him with three daughters of the first marriage.

Richard Griffiths writes:

Mac Rutherford, the founder of the FAAOA and its first Chairman, died on 23 May, aged 91.  Born in Blackpool, later living in Cheshire, he was educated at Merton House school, Penmeanmawr, North Wales and then at Oundle from 1935 to 1939.

He volunteered for the Fleet Air Arm, joining St. Vincent in 1940, followed by EFTS at Luton on Magisters, and then to Canada for SFTS on Harvards at Kingston, Ontario.  He finished, with pilot’s wings and ‘above average’ assessment, in January 1942.  Back in the UK he underwent operational training at Crail, Arbroath and Machrihanish (for Night Flying) on Swordfish and Albacores, again being assessed as ‘above average’. This was despite having hit and destroyed two cows (to a Scottish farmer’s great fury) on a night flying exercise and in the process losing his Swordfish’s starboard undercarriage and part of both starboard mainplane and aileron, before safely crash landing at a nearby airfield.

In August 1942 he joined 841 NAS, on Albacores, initially at Middle Wallop and Machrihanish and then at RAF Manston from September 1942 to December 1943. During the whole of this period he was regularly involved in night patrols, searches and bombing strikes against German E and R Boats off the French coast in the Dover Straits and Channel, frequently under heavy ‘flak’ from both sea and shore.  In one strike in August 1943 he sank 2 E-Boats and probably damaged another on a second sortie after returning to Manston to rearm.  He was subsequently awarded the DSC for ‘great courage and enterprise’ for his part in some 30 of these operations.

The squadron was reformed, after temporary disbandment, in February 1944 and Mac rejoined it, as Senior Pilot, for conversion to Barracudas.  On completion, he was appointed in June 1944 as an Instructor on Barracudas at Crail on 785 and then 786 NASs.  Here he was assessed as an ‘exceptional Instructor Pilot’, before being appointed to 736 NAS, Air Strike Section, SNAW, St. Merryn.  He was then flown out to Australia to join 706 NAS at Schofields and then to 1770 on Fireflys, but VJ day intervened before he could return to ops.  He was demobilised in the UK in April 1946.

He then joined his family woollen textile business in Hawick, before moving to Henley-on-Thames.  He continued to work in the textile industry and became much involved in overseas travel, promoting exports and imports, especially in Scandinavia.  He became Managing Director until the company was amalgamated with another Merchant, when he then joined a new venture of textile agents, importing cloths from Italy and Germany into UK and Scandinavia, until he retired in 1986.

He had returned to flying in July 1947 as a ‘Weekend Pilot. with 1832 RNVR NAS at RNAS Culham, while continuing his civilian weekday work in the textile industry.

In December 1948, promoted to the rank of Lieutenant Commander (A) RNVR, he was appointed CO of 1832 NAS, flying Seafires at Culham.  In July 1949 Mac led the Squadron to sea – the first occasion on which an RNVR squadron had gone to the deck – on HMS Implacable, where he successfully made his first Deck Landing.  Three of his squadron colleagues were less successful, with hair raising pictures of Seafires on their noses against the barrier featuring on the front pages of the more popular newspapers under the heading, Navy Reserves go to Sea.  Nevertheless a total of 269 Deck Landings was achieved in 7 days.  The following year the Squadron enjoyed a more successful and accident free ten days on HMS Theseus.

As well as the regular fortnight’s Continuous Training periods each year at St. Merryn, Culdrose and Ford, Mac took the Squadron to Malta (Hal Far) in 1952, by which time the squadron had converted to the Sea Fury.  Here, as well as participating in a NATO exercise with the Americans, it was inspected by Admiral Lord Louis Mountbatten, who informed Mac of the intention to expand 1832 to a Southern Air Division of four squadrons, with him in overall charge as Commander (A) RNVR.  The Division was based at RAF Benson from June 1953.

In 1955, after another two weeks Continuous Training period on Sea Furys at Hal Far, Mac undertook a Jet Conversion course at Benson on the Vampire Trainer, followed by conversion to the Seahawk, in which he became the first Reservist to land a Jet on a Carrier, HMS Bulwark.  This was during the Division’s last period of Continuous Training, in 1956, before all the RNVR squadrons were disbanded (together with the RAF Auxiliary squadrons) in January 1957.

He then transferred to Naval Intelligence, as Commander RNR, in command of the RNR Photographic Interpretation unit, in which he served until retirement in 1970.  He was awarded the MBE in 1952 and VRD in 1955.

With the disbanding of the RNVR squadrons in 1957 and remembering conversations in Sydney at the end of the war about the need to maintain the camaraderie and friendships developed in the war years, Mac held discussions with the Admiralty, amongst others, about the feasibility of setting up some form of association of naval aircrew and having it formally recognized.  The result was the formation of the Fleet Air Arm Officers’ Association, of which he was the first Chairman and the Founder.

It is self-evident from this, as well as from his long naval career, that Mac was not only a man of vision, but above all a Leader who was more than willingly followed by his colleagues.  He was also a good friend, especially to his squadron contemporaries, who was able to maintain a sensible element of authority without losing his strong sense of humour, his understanding of naval aviators and a readiness to turn a blind eye to the occasional wardroom indiscretion.  He was exactly the right man to be an RNVR Squadron CO.

Mac was married twice; first to Pam, who died in 1953 and with whom he had three daughters, Gail, Gyllian and Fiona; secondly to ‘Babs’ Dooris, who survives him.